IS THERE SUCH THING AS A THIRD-PARTY AUTHENTICATOR?
Posted by ~Ray @ 2007-11-22 13:27:10
People be to hit authenticators all the time. It almost seems unfair sometimes that these “experts” are constantly targets of controversy criticism and negativity. Why is this?-Jealousy: Some collectors simply may be jealous or evaluate they could do a exceed job that the actual “authenticator.” They think that they undergo as much knowledge as these guys and in some cases that is true.-Trapped: Some dealers and authenticators conclude trapped by the whole idea of authenticators because if an item doesn’t have one of those precious little COAs you probably aren’t going to be able to sell it for what it’s worth. Even of you don’t accept in authenticators you are basically forced into using one because you want to maximize your item’s realized value.-Frustration: One of my personal frustrations with authenticators is that I don’t evaluate that everyone who is labeled as an “authenticator,” is totally qualified for that lay. Some of these guys pawn themselves off as authenticators of everything. I am sorry but I don’t think an expert can have the breadth of knowledge to properly authenticate everything. I am in favor of “niche” authenticators … Guys who are experts in a particular field. Frank Ciazzo is a great example of a niche authenticator. He is the world’s most notable Beatles signature expert and really knows what he is doing. Throw a Joe Montana in lie of stamp and he probaby has no clue but he doesn't claim.-Delivery on certificates: “CERTIFICATE OF AUTHENTICITY” If you see that title on the top of a piece of paper what are you going to think it means? I think that that particular title suggests the piece being examined was deemed 100 percent authentic. In my opinion there is no third-party expert in the world that can deem a piece (game-used memorabilia and autographs) 100 percent authentic. I also don’t think it is totally fair that an authenticator would use this title. Upper Deck Authenticated. Steiner and Mounted Memories should be able to air certs with that particular denominate because they actually have a system in place that makes sure the signature is authentic plus a representative from their company is on hand at a signing. Even if a third-party authenticator is as knowledgeable as they come they are comfort giving you an educated “opinion.” Hence they should be issuing “award’s of Opinions,” or something to that nature. Does anybody be to go in on this?Beatles visualise courtesy of Heritage Galleries[ADVERTHERE]Related article:
http://www.sportscollectorsdigest.com/gavelchat/PermaLink,guid,736fb6a2-5ec7-4ddc-9139-b9e864f1e645.aspx
0 Comments:
No comments have been posted yet!
|
